PROGRAM obs_diag (for observations that use the threed_sphere location module)

DART project logo

Jump to DART Documentation Main Index
version information for this file:
$Id: obs_diag.html 12664 2018-06-12 22:04:36Z nancy@ucar.edu $

NAMELIST / INTERFACES / FILES / USAGE / REFERENCES / ERRORS / PLANS / PRIVATE COMPONENTS / TERMS OF USE

Overview

Main program for evaluating filter performance in observation space. Primarily, the prior or posterior ensemble mean (and spread) are compared to the observation and several quantities are calculated. These quantities are then saved in a netCDF file that has all the metadata to create meaningful figures.

Each obs_seq.final file contains an observation sequence that has multiple 'copies' of the observation. One copy is the actual observation, another copy is the prior ensemble mean estimate of the observation, one is the spread of the prior ensemble estimate, one may be the prior estimate from ensemble member 1, ... etc. If the original observation sequence is the result of a 'perfect model' experiment, there is an additional copy called the 'truth' - the noise-free expected observation given the true model state. Since this copy does not, in general, exist for the high-order models, all comparisons are made with the copy labelled 'observation'. There is also a namelist variable (use_zero_error_obs) to compare against the 'truth' instead; the observation error variance is then automatically set to zero.

Each ensemble member applies a forward observation operator to the state to compute the "expected" value of an observation. Please note: the forward observation operator is applied AFTER any prior inflation has taken place! Similarly, the forward observation operator is applied AFTER any posterior inflation. This has always been the case. For a detailed look at the relationship between the observation operators and inflation, please look at the Detailed Program Execution Flow section of filter.html.

Given multiple estimates of the observation, several quantities can be calculated. It is possible to compute the expected observations from the state vector before assimilating (the "guess", "forecast", or "prior") or after the assimilation (the "analysis", or "posterior").

Even with input.nml:filter_nml:num_output_obs_members set to 0; the full [prior,posterior] ensemble mean and [prior,posterior] ensemble spread are preserved in the obs_seq.final file. Consequently, the ensemble means and spreads are used to calculate the diagnostics. If the input.nml:filter_nml:num_output_obs_members is set to 80 (for example); the first 80 ensemble members prior and posterior "expected" values of the observation are also included. In this case, the obs_seq.final file contains enough information to calculate a rank histograms, verify forecasts, etc. The ensemble means are still used for many other calculations.

Since this program is fundamentally interested in the response as a function of region, there are three versions of this program; one for each of the oned, threed_sphere, or threed_cartesian location modules (location_mod.f90). It did not make sense to ask the lorenz_96 model what part of North America you'd like to investigate or how you would like to bin in the vertical. The low-order models write out similar netCDF files and the Matlab scripts have been updated accordingly. The oned observations have locations conceptualized as being on a unit circle, so only the namelist input variables pertaining to longitude are used.

Identity observations (only possible from "perfect model experiments") are already explored with state-space diagnostics, so obs_diag simply skips them.

obs_diag is designed to explore the effect of the assimilation in three ways; 1) as a function of time for a particular variable and level (this is the figure on the left), 2) as a time-averaged vertical profile (figure in the middle), and sometimes 3) in terms of a rank histogram - "Where does the actual observation rank relative to the rest of the ensemble?" (figures on the right). The figures on the left and center were created by several Matlab® scripts that query the obs_diag_output.nc file: DART/diagnostics/matlab/plot_evolution.m and plot_profile.m. Both of these takes as input a file name and a 'quantity' to plot ('rmse','spread','totalspread', ...) and exhaustively plots the quantity (for every variable, every level, every region) in a single matlab figure window - and creates a series of .ps files with multiple pages for each of the figures. The directory gets cluttered with them. The rank histogram information can easily be plotted with ncview, a free third-party piece of software or with plot_rank_histogram.m.

obs_diag can be configured to compare the ensemble estimates against the 'observation' copy or the 'truth' copy based on the setting of the use_zero_error_obs namelist variable.

The observation sequence files contain only the time of the observation, nothing of the assimilation interval, etc. - so it requires user guidance to declare what sort of temporal binning for the temporal evolution plots. I do a 'bunch' of arithmetic on the namelist times to convert them to a series of temporal bin edges that are used when traversing the observation sequence. The actual algorithm is that the user input for the start date and bin width set up a sequence that ends in one of two ways ... the last time is reached or the number of bins has been reached.

obs_diag reads obs_seq.final files and calculates the following quantities (in no particular order) for an arbitrary number of regions and levels. obs_diag creates a netCDF file called obs_diag_output.nc. It is necessary to query the CopyMetaData variable to determine the storage order (i.e. "which copy is what?") if you want to use your own plotting routines.

ncdump -f F -v CopyMetaData obs_diag_output.nc


Nposs The number of observations available to be assimilated.
Nused The number of observations that were assimilated.
NbadUV the number of velocity observations that had a matching component that was not assimilated;
NbadLV the number of observations that were above or below the highest or lowest model level, respectively;
rmse The root-mean-squared error (the horizontal wind components are also used to calculate the vector wind velocity and its RMS error).
bias The simple sum of forecast - observation. The bias of the horizontal wind speed (not velocity) is also computed.
spread The standard deviation of the univariate obs. DART does not exploit the bivariate nature of U,V winds and so the spread of the horizontal wind is defined as the sum of the spreads of the U and V components.
totalspread    The total standard deviation of the estimate. We pool the ensemble variance of the observation plus the observation error variance and take the square root.
NbadDARTQC    the number of observations that had a DART QC value (> 1 for a prior, > 3 for a posterior)
observation the mean of the observation values
ens_mean the ensemble mean of the model estimates of the observation values
N_trusted the number of implicitly trusted observations, regardless of DART QC
N_DARTqc_0 the number of observations that had a DART QC value of 0
N_DARTqc_1 the number of observations that had a DART QC value of 1
N_DARTqc_2 the number of observations that had a DART QC value of 2
N_DARTqc_3 the number of observations that had a DART QC value of 3
N_DARTqc_4 the number of observations that had a DART QC value of 4
N_DARTqc_5 the number of observations that had a DART QC value of 5
N_DARTqc_6 the number of observations that had a DART QC value of 6
N_DARTqc_7 the number of observations that had a DART QC value of 7
N_DARTqc_8 the number of observations that had a DART QC value of 8

The temporal evolution of the above quantities for every observation type (RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT, AIRCRAFT_SPECIFIC_HUMIDITY, ...) is recorded in the output netCDF file - obs_diag_output.nc. This netCDF file can then be loaded and displayed using the Matlab® scripts in ..../DART/diagnostics/matlab. (which may depend on functions in ..../DART/matlab). The temporal, geographic, and vertical binning are under namelist control. Temporal averages of the above quantities are also stored in the netCDF file. Normally, it is useful to skip the 'burn-in' period - the amount of time to skip is under namelist control.

The DART QC flag is intended to provide information about whether the observation was assimilated, evaluated only, whether the assimilation resulted in a 'good' observation, etc. DART QC values lower than 2 indicate the prior and posteriors are OK. DART QC values higher than 3 were not assimilated or evaluated. Here is the table that should explain things more fully:

DART QC flag valuemeaning
0observation assimilated
1observation evaluated only (because of namelist settings)

2assimilated, but the posterior forward operator failed
3evaluated only, but the posterior forward operator failed

4prior forward operator failed
5not used because observation type not listed in namelist
6rejected because incoming observation QC too large
7rejected because of a failed outlier threshold test
8vertical conversion failed
9+reserved for future use

[top]

What is new in the Manhattan Release.

  1. Support for DART QC = 8 (failed vertical conversion).

  2. Simplified input file specification.

  3. Removed rat_cri and input_qc_threshold from the namelists. They had been deprecated for quite some time.

  4. Some of the internal variable names have been changed to make it easier to distinguish between variances and standard deviations.

What is new in the Lanai Release.

obs_diag has several improvements:

  1. Improved vertical specification. Namelist variables [h,p,m]level_edges allow fine-grained control over the vertical binning. It is not allowed to specify both the edges and midpoints for the vertical bins.

  2. Improved error-checking for input specification, particularly the vertical bins. Repeated values are squeezed out.

  3. Support for 'trusted' observations. Trusted observation types may be specified in the namelist and all observations of that type will be counted in the statistics despite the DART QC code (as long as the forward observation operator succeeds). See namelist variable trusted_obs. For more details, see the section on Trusted observations.

  4. Support for 'true' observations (i.e. from an OSSE). If the 'truth' copy of an observation is desired for comparison (instead of the default copy) the observation error variance is set to 0.0 and the statistics are calculated relative to the 'truth' copy (as opposed to the normal 'noisy' or 'observation' copy). See namelist variable use_zero_error_obs.

  5. discontinued the use of rat_cri and input_qc_threshold namelist variables. Their functionality was replaced by the DART QC mechanism long ago.

  6. The creation of the rank histogram (if possible) is now namelist-controlled by namelist variable create_rank_histogram.

[top]

NAMELIST

This namelist is read from the file input.nml. Namelists start with an ampersand '&' and terminate with a slash '/'. Character strings that contain a '/' must be enclosed in quotes to prevent them from prematurely terminating the namelist.

&obs_diag_nml
   obs_sequence_name     = ''
   obs_sequence_list     = ''
   first_bin_center      =  2003, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0
   last_bin_center       =  2003, 1, 2, 0, 0, 0
   bin_separation        =     0, 0, 0, 6, 0, 0
   bin_width             =     0, 0, 0, 6, 0, 0
   time_to_skip          =     0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0
   max_num_bins          = 1000
   plevel                = -888888.0
   hlevel                = -888888.0
   mlevel                = -888888
   plevel_edges          = -888888.0
   hlevel_edges          = -888888.0
   mlevel_edges          = -888888
   Nregions              = 0
   lonlim1               = -888888.0
   lonlim2               = -888888.0
   latlim1               = -888888.0
   latlim2               = -888888.0
   reg_names             = 'null'
   trusted_obs           = 'null'
   create_rank_histogram = .true.
   outliers_in_histogram = .false.
   use_zero_error_obs    = .false.
   verbose               = .false.
   /

These values may be more useful:

   obs_sequence_list     = 'input_file_list.txt'
   plevel     = 1000, 925, 850, 700, 500, 400, 300, 250, 200, 150, 100,
   -or- plevel_edges = 1050, 962.5, 887.5, 775, 600, 450, 350, 275, 225, 175, 125, 75
   hlevel     = 1000, 2000, 3000, 4000, 5000, 6000, 7000, 8000, 9000, 10000, 11000,
   -or- hlevel_edges = 0, 1500, 2500, 3500, 4500, 5500, 6500,
   mlevel     = 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11,
   -or- mlevel_edges = 0.5, 1.5, 2.5, 3.5, 10.5,
   Nregions              = 4
   lonlim1               =   0.0,   0.0,   0.0, 235.0
   lonlim2               = 360.0, 360.0, 360.0, 295.0
   latlim1               =  20.0, -80.0, -20.0,  25.0
   latlim2               =  80.0, -20.0,  20.0,  55.0
   reg_names             = 'Northern Hemisphere', 'Southern Hemisphere', 'Tropics', 'North America'


The date-time integer arrays in this namelist have the form (YYYY, MM, DY, HR, MIN, SEC).
The allowable ranges for the region boundaries are: latitude [-90.,90], longitude [0.,Inf.]

You can only specify either obs_sequence_name or obs_sequence_list -- not both. One of them has to be an empty string ... i.e. ''.

Item Type Description
obs_sequence_name character(len=256), dimension(100) An array of names of observation sequence files. These may be relative or absolute filenames. If this is set, obs_sequence_list must be set to ' ' (empty string).
obs_sequence_list character(len=256) Name of an ascii text file which contains a list of one or more observation sequence files, one per line. If this is specified, obs_sequence_name must be set to ' '. Can be created by any method, including sending the output of the 'ls' command to a file, a text editor, or another program. If this is set, obs_sequence_name must be set to ' ' (empty string).
first_bin_center integer, dimension(6) first timeslot of the first obs_seq.final file to process. The six integers are: year, month, day, hour, hour, minute, second, in that order. obs_diag has improved run-time output that reports the time and date of the first and last observations in every observation sequence file. Look for the string 'First observation date' in the logfile. If the verbose is 'true', it is also written to the screen.
last_bin_center integer, dimension(6) last timeslot of interest. (reminder: the last timeslot of day 1 is hour 0 of day 2) The six integers are: year, month, day, hour, hour, minute, second, in that order. This does not need to be exact, the values from first_bin_center and bin_separation are used to populate the time array and stop on or before the time defined by last_bin_center. See also max_num_bins.
bin_separation integer, dimension(6) Time between bin centers. The year and month values must be zero.
bin_width integer, dimension(6) Time span around bin centers in which obs will be compared. The year and month values must be zero. Frequently, but not required to be, the same as the values for bin_separation. 0
time_to_skip integer, dimension(6) Time span at the beginning to skip when calculating vertical profiles of rms error and bias. The year and month values must be zero. Useful because it takes some time for the assimilation to settle down from the climatological spread at the start. time_to_skip is an amount of time AFTER the first edge of the first bin.
max_num_bins integer This provides an alternative way to declare the last_bin_center. If max_num_bins is set to '10', only 10 timesteps will be output - provided last_bin_center is set to some later date.
plevel real, dimension(50) The midpoints defining the pressure levels for the vertical binning. There is no specification of bin width - a continuum is used. If a single midpoint value is entered, the bin edges are +/- 10% of the midpoint value. If you'd like to change that see the routine Rmidpoints2edges(). You may specify either plevel or plevel_edges, but not both.
plevel_edges real, dimension(51) The edges defining the pressure levels for the vertical binning. You may specify either plevel or plevel_edges, but not both.
hlevel real, dimension(50) Same, but for observations that have height(m) or depth(m) as the vertical coordinate.
hlevel_edges real, dimension(51) The edges defining the height (or depth) levels for the vertical binning. You may specify either hlevel or hlevel_edges, but not both.
mlevel real, dimension(50) Same, but for observations that have model level as the vertical coordinate.
mlevel_edges real, dimension(51) The edges defining the model levels for the vertical binning. You may specify either mlevel or mlevel_edges, but not both.
Nregions integer Number of regions of the globe for which obs space diagnostics are computed separately. Must be between [1,50]. If 50 is not enough, increase obs_diag.f90MaxRegions and recompile.
lonlim1 real, dimension(50) Westernmost longitudes of each of the regions.
lonlim2 real, dimension(50) Easternmost longitudes of each of the regions. If any of these values is less than the westernmost values, it defines a region that spans the prime meridian. e.g. a specification of lonlim1 = 330 , lonlim2 = 50 could identify a region like "Africa".
latlim1 real, dimension(50) Southernmost latitudes of the regions.
latlim2 real, dimension(50) Northernmost latitudes of the regions.
reg_names character(len=129), dimension(50) Array of names for the regions to be analyzed. Will be used for plot titles.
trusted_obs character(len=32), dimension(50) list of observation types that must participate in the calculation of the statistics, regardless of the DART QC (provided that the forward observation operator can still be applied without failure). e.g. 'RADIOSONDE_TEMPERATURE', ... For more details, see the section on Trusted observations.
use_zero_error_obs logical if .true., the observation copy used for the statistics calculations will be 'truth'. Only 'perfect' observations (from perfect_model_obs) have this copy. The observation error variance will be set to zero.
create_rank_histogram logical if .true. and there are actual ensemble estimates of the observations in the obs_seq.final (i.e. filter_nml:num_output_obs_members is larger than zero), a rank histogram will be created.
outliers_in_histogram logical if .true. the observations that have been rejected by the outlier threshhold mechanism will be included in the calculation of the rank histogram.
verbose logical switch controlling amount of run-time output.

[top]

OTHER MODULES USED

obs_sequence_mod
obs_kind_mod
obs_def_mod (and possibly other obs_def_xxx mods)
assim_model_mod
random_seq_mod
model_mod
location_mod
types_mod
time_manager_mod
utilities_mod
sort_mod

[top]

FILES

Obs_diag may require a model input file from which to get grid information, metadata, and links to modules providing the models expected observations. It all depends on what's needed by the model_mod.f90

Discussion of obs_diag_output.nc

Every observation type encountered in the observation sequence file is tracked separately, and aggregated into temporal and 3D spatial bins. There are two main efforts to this program. One is to track the temporal evolution of any of the quantities available in the netCDF file for any possible observation type:

ncdump -v CopyMetaData,ObservationTypes obs_diag_output.nc

The other is to explore the vertical profile of a particular observation kind. By default, each observation kind has a 'guess/prior' value and an 'analysis/posterior' value - which shed some insight into the innovations.


temporal evolution

The obs_diag_output.nc output file has all the metadata I could think of, as well as separate variables for every observation type in the observation sequence file. Furthermore, there is a separate variable for the 'guess/prior' and 'analysis/posterior' estimate of the observation. To distinguish between the two, a suffix is appended to the variable name. An example seems appropriate:

  ...
  char CopyMetaData(copy, stringlength) ;
          CopyMetaData:long_name = "quantity names" ;
  char ObservationTypes(obstypes, stringlength) ;
          ObservationTypes:long_name = "DART observation types" ;
          ObservationTypes:comment = "table relating integer to observation type string" ;
  float RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_guess(time, copy, plevel, region) ;
          RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_guess:_FillValue = -888888.f ;
          RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_guess:missing_value = -888888.f ;
  float RADIOSONDE_V_WIND_COMPONENT_guess(time, copy, plevel, region) ;
          RADIOSONDE_V_WIND_COMPONENT_guess:_FillValue = -888888.f ;
          RADIOSONDE_V_WIND_COMPONENT_guess:missing_value = -888888.f ;
  ...
  float MARINE_SFC_ALTIMETER_guess(time, copy, surface, region) ;
          MARINE_SFC_ALTIMETER_guess:_FillValue = -888888.f ;
          MARINE_SFC_ALTIMETER_guess:missing_value = -888888.f ;
  ...
  float RADIOSONDE_WIND_VELOCITY_guess(time, copy, plevel, region) ;
          RADIOSONDE_WIND_VELOCITY_guess:_FillValue = -888888.f ;
          RADIOSONDE_WIND_VELOCITY_guess:missing_value = -888888.f ;
  ...
  float RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_analy(time, copy, plevel, region) ;
          RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_analy:_FillValue = -888888.f ;
          RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_analy:missing_value = -888888.f ;
  float RADIOSONDE_V_WIND_COMPONENT_analy(time, copy, plevel, region) ;
          RADIOSONDE_V_WIND_COMPONENT_analy:_FillValue = -888888.f ;
          RADIOSONDE_V_WIND_COMPONENT_analy:missing_value = -888888.f ;
  ...

There are several things to note:

  1. the 'WIND_VELOCITY' component is nowhere 'near' the corresponding U,V components.
  2. all of the 'guess' variables come before the matching 'analy' variables.
  3. surface variables (i.e. MARINE_SFC_ALTIMETER have a coordinate called 'surface' as opposed to 'plevel' for the others in this example).


vertical profiles

Believe it or not, there are another set of netCDF variables specifically for the vertical profiles, essentially duplicating the previous variables but without the 'time' dimension. These are distinguished by the suffix added to the observation kind - 'VPguess' and 'VPanaly' - 'VP' for Vertical Profile.

  ...
  float SAT_WIND_VELOCITY_VPguess(copy, plevel, region) ;
          SAT_WIND_VELOCITY_VPguess:_FillValue = -888888.f ;
          SAT_WIND_VELOCITY_VPguess:missing_value = -888888.f ;
  ...
  float RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_VPanaly(copy, plevel, region) ;
          RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_VPanaly:_FillValue = -888888.f ;
          RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_VPanaly:missing_value = -888888.f ;
  ...

Observations flagged as 'surface' do not participate in the vertical profiles (Because surface variables cannot exist on any other level, there's not much to plot!). Observations on the lowest level DO participate. There's a difference!


rank histograms

If it is possible to calculate a rank histogram, there will also be :

   ...
   int RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_guess_RankHi(time, rank_bins, plevel, region) ;
   ...
   int RADIOSONDE_V_WIND_COMPONENT_guess_RankHi(time, rank_bins, plevel, region) ;
   ...
   int MARINE_SFC_ALTIMETER_guess_RankHist(time, rank_bins, surface, region) ;
   ...

as well as some global attributes. The attributes reflect the namelist settings and can be used by plotting routines to provide additional annotation for the histogram.

		:DART_QCs_in_histogram = 0, 1, 2, 3, 7 ;
		:outliers_in_histogram = "TRUE" ;

Please note:

  1. netCDF restricts variable names to 40 characters, so '_Rank_Hist' may be truncated.
  2. It is sufficiently vague to try to calculate a rank histogram for a velocity derived from the assimilation of U,V components such that NO rank histogram is created for velocity. A run-time log message will inform as to which variables are NOT having a rank histogram variable preserved in the obs_diag_output.nc file - IFF it is possible to calculate a rank histogram in the first place.
Instructions for viewing the rank histogram with ncview.
Instructions for viewing the rank histogram with Matlab.


"Trusted" observation types

This needs to be stated up front: obs_diag is a post-processor; it cannot influence the assimilation. One interpretation of a TRUSTED observation is that the assimilation should always use the observation, even if it is far from the ensemble. At present (23 Feb 2015), the filter in DART does not forcibly assimilate any one observation and selectively assimilate the others. Still, it is useful to explore the results using a set of 'trusted type' observations, whether they were assimilated, evaluated, or rejected by the outlier threshhold. This is the important distinction. The diagnostics can be calculated differently for each observation type.

The normal diagnostics calculate the metrics (rmse, bias, etc.) only for the 'good' observations - those that were assimilated or evaluated. The outlier_threshold essentially defines what observations are considered too far from the ensemble prior to be useful. These observations get a DART QC of 7 and are not assimilated. The observations with a DART QC of 7 do not contribute the the metrics being calculated. Similarly, if the forward observation operator fails, these observations cannot contribute. When the operator fails, the 'expected' observation value is 'MISSING', and there is no ensemble mean or spread.

'Trusted type' observation metrics are calculated using all the observations that were assimilated or evaluated AND the observations that were rejected by the outlier threshhold. obs_diag can post-process the DART QC and calculate the metrics appropriately for observation types listed in the trusted_obs namelist variable. If there are trusted observation types specified for obs_diag, the obs_diag_output.nc has global metadata to indicate that a different set of criteria were used to calculate the metrics. The individual variables also have an extra attribute. In the following output, input.nml:obs_diag_nml:trusted_obs was set: trusted_obs = 'RADIOSONDE_TEMPERATURE', 'RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT'

  ...
        float RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_guess(time, copy, plevel, region) ;
                RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_guess:_FillValue = -888888.f ;
                RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_guess:missing_value = -888888.f ;
                RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT_guess:TRUSTED = "TRUE" ;
        float RADIOSONDE_V_WIND_COMPONENT_guess(time, copy, plevel, region) ;
                RADIOSONDE_V_WIND_COMPONENT_guess:_FillValue = -888888.f ;
                RADIOSONDE_V_WIND_COMPONENT_guess:missing_value = -888888.f ;
  ...
// global attributes:
  ...
                :trusted_obs_01 = "RADIOSONDE_TEMPERATURE" ;
                :trusted_obs_02 = "RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT" ;
                :obs_seq_file_001 = "cam_obs_seq.1978-01-01-00000.final" ;
                :obs_seq_file_002 = "cam_obs_seq.1978-01-02-00000.final" ;
                :obs_seq_file_003 = "cam_obs_seq.1978-01-03-00000.final" ;
  ...
                :MARINE_SFC_ALTIMETER = 7 ;
                :LAND_SFC_ALTIMETER = 8 ;
                :RADIOSONDE_U_WIND_COMPONENT--TRUSTED = 10 ;
                :RADIOSONDE_V_WIND_COMPONENT = 11 ;
                :RADIOSONDE_TEMPERATURE--TRUSTED = 14 ;
                :RADIOSONDE_SPECIFIC_HUMIDITY = 15 ;
                :AIRCRAFT_U_WIND_COMPONENT = 21 ;
  ...
The Matlab scripts try to ensure that the trusted observation graphics clarify that the metrics plotted are somehow 'different' than the normal processing stream. Some text is added to indicate that the values include the outlying observations. IMPORTANT: The interpretation of the number of observations 'possible' and 'used' still reflects what was used in the assimilation! The number of observations rejected by the outlier threshhold is not explicilty plotted. To reinforce this, the text for the observation axis on all graphics has been changed to "o=possible, *=assimilated". In short, the distance between the number of observations possible and the number assimilated still reflects the number of observations rejected by the outlier threshhold and the number of failed forward observation operators.   

There is ONE ambiguous case for trusted observations. There may be instances in which the observation fails the outlier threshhold test (which is based on the prior) and the posterior forward operator fails. DART does not have a QC that explicilty covers this case. The current logic in obs_diag correctly handles these cases except when trying to use 'trusted' observations. There is a section of code in obs_diag that may be enabled if you are encountering this ambiguous case. As obs_diag runs, a warning message is issued and a summary count is printed if the ambiguous case is encountered. What normally happens is that if that specific observation type is trusted, the posterior values include a MISSING value in the calculation which makes them inaccurate. If the block of code is enabled, the DART QC is recast as the PRIOR forward observation operator fails. This is technically incorrect, but for the case of trusted observations, it results in only calculating statistics for trusted observations that have a useful prior and posterior. This should not be used unless you are willing to intentionally disregard 'trusted' observations that were rejected by the outlier threshhold. Since the whole point of a trusted observation is to include observations potentially rejected by the outlier threshhold, you see the problem. Some people like to compare the posteriors. THAT can be the problem.

         if ((qc_integer == 7) .and. (abs(posterior_mean(1) - MISSING_R8) < 1.0_r8)) then
            write(string1,*)'WARNING ambiguous case for obs index ',obsindex
            string2 = 'obs failed outlier threshhold AND posterior operator failed.'
            string3 = 'Counting as a Prior QC == 7, Posterior QC == 4.'
            if (trusted) then
! COMMENT      string3 = 'WARNING changing DART QC from 7 to 4'
! COMMENT      qc_integer = 4
            endif
            call error_handler(E_MSG,'obs_diag',string1,text2=string2,text3=string3)
            num_ambiguous = num_ambiguous + 1
         endif

[top]

USAGE

obs_diag is built in .../DART/models/your_model/work, in the same way as the other DART components.

multiple observation sequence files

There are two ways to specify input files for obs_diag. You can either specify the name of a file containing a list of files (in obs_sequence_list), or you may specify a list of files via obs_sequence_name.

Example: observation sequence files spanning 30 days.

In this example, we will be accumulating metrics for 30 days over the entire globe. The obs_diag_output.nc file will have exactly ONE timestep in it (so it won't be much use for the plot_evolution functions) - but the plot_profile functions and the plot_rank_histogram function will be used to explore the assimilation. By way of an example, we will NOT be using outlier observations in the rank histogram. Lets presume that all your obs_seq.final files are in alphabetically-nice directories:   
/Exp1/Dir01/obs_seq.final
/Exp1/Dir02/obs_seq.final
/Exp1/Dir03/obs_seq.final
...
/Exp1/Dir99/obs_seq.final

The first step is to create a file containing the list of observation sequence files you want to use. This can be done with the unix command 'ls' with the -1 option (that's a number one) to put one file per line.

ls -1 /Exp1/Dir*/obs_seq.final > obs_file_list.txt

It is necessary to turn on the verbose option to check the first/last times that will be used for the histogram. Then, the namelist settings for 2008 07 31 12Z through 2008 08 30 12Z are:

&obs_diag_nml
   obs_sequence_name     = ''
   obs_sequence_list     = 'obs_file_list.txt'
   first_bin_center      =  2008, 8,15,12, 0, 0
   last_bin_center       =  2008, 8,15,12, 0, 0
   bin_separation        =     0, 0,30, 0, 0, 0
   bin_width             =     0, 0,30, 0, 0, 0
   time_to_skip          =     0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0
   max_num_bins          = 1000
   Nregions              = 1
   lonlim1               =   0.0
   lonlim2               = 360.0
   latlim1               = -90.0
   latlim2               =  90.0
   reg_names             = 'Entire Domain'
   create_rank_histogram = .true.
   outliers_in_histogram = .false.
   verbose               = .true.
   /

then, simply run obs_diag in the usual manner - you may want to save the run-time output to a file. Here is a portion of the run-time output:

...
Region  1 Entire Domain                    (WESN):     0.0000   360.0000   -90.0000    90.0000
 Requesting            1  assimilation periods.

epoch      1  start day=148865, sec=43201
epoch      1 center day=148880, sec=43200
epoch      1    end day=148895, sec=43200
epoch      1  start 2008 Jul 31 12:00:01
epoch      1 center 2008 Aug 15 12:00:00
epoch      1    end 2008 Aug 30 12:00:00
...
MARINE_SFC_HORIZONTAL_WIND_guess_RankHis has            0 "rank"able observations.
SAT_HORIZONTAL_WIND_guess_RankHist       has            0 "rank"able observations.
...

Discussion: It should be pretty clear that there is exactly 1 assimilation period, it may surprise you that the start is 1 second past 12Z. This is deliberate and reflects the DART convention of starting intervals 1 second after the end of the previous interval. The times in the netCDF variables reflect the defined start/stop of the period, regardless of the time of the first/last observation.

Please note that none of the 'horizontal_wind' variables will have a rank histogram, so they are not written to the netCDF file. ANY variable that does not have a rank histogram with some observations will NOT have a rank histogram variable in the netCDF file.

Now that you have the obs_diag_output.nc, you can explore it with plot_profile.m, plot_bias_xxx_profile.m, or plot_rmse_xxx_profile.m, and look at the rank histograms with ncview or plot_rank_histogram.m.

[top]

REFERENCES

  1. none

[top]

ERROR CODES and CONDITIONS

RoutineMessageComment
obs_diag No first observation in sequence. get_first_obs couldn't find a "first obs" in the obs_seq.final.
obs_diag No last observation in sequence get_last_obs couldn't find a "last obs" in the obs_seq.final
obs_diag metadata incomplete Couldn't find the index for the observation value in the observation sequence file. It is the only one that is required.
filter_get_obs_info Vertical coordinate not recognized It must be "surface", "pressure", or "height"
Convert2Time namelist parameter out-of-bounds. Fix and try again bin_width, bin_separation, and time_to_skip must have year = 0 and month = 0

KNOWN BUGS

none at this time

[top]

FUTURE PLANS

The RMSE of the vector wind velocity is being used. The bias is actually the bias of the wind speed, with no regard to direction. Seems like this is not consistent ...

Use log(p) instead of pressure for binning/plotting.

Hope to have a separate DART QC flag for observations outside the model state. Right now, all observations that have a DARt forward operator fail (extrapolate, mainly) get counted as observations that are rejected. Logically, these observations are not possible because most (all?) DART observation operators cannot extrapolate.

If the specified levels are not in the proper range for the observations, no vertical profile is built. The 'verbose' option should highlight the fact there are no observations in the specified vertical bins - AND provide some sort of guidance about the min and max values of the vertical values.

[top]

PRIVATE COMPONENTS

N/A

[top]

Terms of Use

DART software - Copyright UCAR. This open source software is provided by UCAR, "as is", without charge, subject to all terms of use at http://www.image.ucar.edu/DAReS/DART/DART_download

Contact: Tim Hoar
Revision: $Revision: 12664 $
Source: $URL: https://svn-dares-dart.cgd.ucar.edu/DART/releases/Manhattan/assimilation_code/programs/obs_diag/threed_sphere/obs_diag.html $
Change Date: $Date: 2018-06-12 16:04:36 -0600 (Tue, 12 Jun 2018) $
Change history:  try "svn log" or "svn diff"